Click Here to be helped in California!


Pregnant? Click Here
China Adoption Blog

04/19/07

Cultural connections and international adaptation.

Posted by : grant in China Adoption Blog at 12:28 pm , 480 words, 159 views  
Categories: Adoption Process, Family Life, How To...
detail of a fresco by Giovanni Domenico Tiepolo, taken from the wikimedia commons public domain archive

Detail of an 18th century fresco
by Giovanni Domenico Tiepolo

I've been thinking lately about the idea of maintaining my kids' heritage, and what "heritage" means, and the extent to which an American of recent Euro-African descent can actually somehow embody Chinese culture. My conclusion: I can't. I can only embody international adoption as its own culture within America, and maybe make sure a couple language lessons get given. But I'm interested in what I'm reading about other ways people are 1. defining that international adoption-as-culture and 2. dealing with issues of heritage, race and culture.

There's been an interesting piece in the New Haven Register on international adaptation, which is a phrase I'm going to rip off, and classes (or, what, "consciousness-raising exercises") for transracial families.

For example, they still have to answer a lot of questions and assumptions based on their race from people who challenge whether or not they’re American. Such tauntings may lead a child to question who they really are, especially when they reach adolescence and high school.

"Our society doesn’t see me as a McGinniss but as an Asian woman. Our attempt to address this kind of dichotomy has been to give children a lot of pride in their heritage," but it may not be enough, she said.

SPONSOR


I'm interested in what McGinniss' classes are actually like.

(Compare that to thoughts on naming at Twice the Rice, about which more in a later blog entry.)

Similar thoughts are addressed (and left unaddressed) in the Bennington Banner's piece on "honoring heritage", which has a single quote that seems to say a lot:
"It's so wonderful to share Chinese culture with children," said Ai Ping, "especially because they would not learn the language any other way."

Ai Ping is a language teacher who says much in few words.

The article really drills home the message that these kids have a heritage and culture that must be respected and celebrated. You see that a lot in writings about adoption. What I don't see all that often (although Cheri Register gets into it in one of her books) is people talking about how impossible it is to share a heritage and culture which isn't actually your own. Culture is a thing that goes deeper than a couple big meals a couple times a year and some funky clothes that get trotted out a couple other times a year. Language? Makes travel easier, and communication easier. But it's just the beginning (and to be honest, I haven't even started that).

So how does a non-Chinese person engage with Chinese culture?

That's a question I can't pretend to answer (although, as that "Chinese Culture" category just to the right of these words makes obvious, it's something that fascinates me).

How do I share it with my children?

I dunno. I'll let you know when it happens. You got any ideas?

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
I do not know either, it will be an issue for me in the future if all goes well, but I feel like I cross cultural lines all the time (Miso soup for breakfast, listening to Japanese rock... an interest in cultures in general)
hmmm

Also I must learn more about Vietnam and everything in general...
I'm still not sure what culture IS or if I have a specific one... or if I just have one of my own that is very odd...
PermalinkPermalink 04/19/07 @ 17:04
Comment from: grant [Member] Email · http://china.adoptionblogs.com/
The 20th century seemed to be all about the emergence of sub-cultures -- I think that's probably some unanticipated consequence of the Industrial Revolution. Before a certain point (invention of the automobile, steam liner, railway), I think what we think of as culture was simply a local way of doing things. The more people traveled, though, the more people thought about different ways doing things.

PermalinkPermalink 04/20/07 @ 08:14
Comment from: bugmenot [Member] Email
Culture is obsolete. Regionalism is dead. Nationalism isn't too far behind. I am an army of one. Once the alien space ships start landing, there will be a surge of planetism but that, too, will fade with time.

Macro is out. Micro is in. Your kids' culture is that of House Grant.

If there are things about China you like, incorporate those things into your family. Make them part of House Grant. But, don't feel you have to incorporate things about China just because that is where the blood line runs.

Both my family and Sarah's have traditions. Some we will expose Malcolm to and others we will retire. It need be no more difficult than that.
PermalinkPermalink 04/23/07 @ 10:43
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

AdoptHelp
Choose an Option









Pregnant?
click here
AdoptHelp.com

Misc

Subscribe to China Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 461